| 1 | Ron Kochman | (16) | 1,275 |
| 2 | Steven "The Dude" Ritter | (11) | 771 |
| 3 | Ray Villwock | (15) | 737 |
| 4 | Carmelo Barbieri | (14) | 689 |
| 5 | Big Rob | (7) | 610 |
| 6 | Jimmy Chang | (10) | 599 |
| 7 | Doc Brown | (14) | 560 |
| 8 | Frank "The Prez" Preziosi | (9) | 468 |
| 9 | Shahar "The Mossad" Zlochover | (6) | 463 |
| 10 | John Almeida | (5) | 401 |
| 11 | Lynn Greco | (5) | 286 |
| 12 | Jessica Thompson | (4) | 212 |
| 13 | Kyle Whittaker | (3) | 203 |
| 14 | Kat "wildcat" Forte | (4) | 199 |
| 15 | The Souless One | (3) | 190 |
| 16 | Eric "FOZZIE" Nalitt | (3) | 169 |
| 17 | Steve Kennedy | (3) | 140 |
| 18 | Patrick "POOKIE" Boyle | (1) | 122 |
| 19 | Dustin Hamilton | (1) | 104 |
| 20 | Johnny Neal | (4) | 99 |
| 21 | Rose Competiello | (2) | 90 |
| 22 | Peggy Franklin | (2) | 88 |
| 23 | Adam Greene | (2) | 86 |
| 24 | Chris "The Hatchet" Weaver | (1) | 80 |
| 25 | Clayton Bigsby | (1) | 70 |